| Hydraulic Performance | k ≤ 10⁻¹² m/s (HDPE geomembrane) | k ≤ 5 x 10⁻¹¹ m/s (GCL alone) | k ≤ 10⁻¹² m/s (composite) | Single barrier: Carbofol®. Secondary mineral layer required: add Bentofix® |
| Chemical Resistance | Excellent — HDPE highly resistant to a wide pH range | CAUTION: Standard sodium bentonite GCL (Bentofix®) is unsuitable where tailings leachate pH < 4 or where high concentrations of polyvalent cations (Ca2+, Mg2+, heavy metals) are present — these ions displace Na+ in the bentonite, causing an irreversible hydraulic conductivity increase. Specify Bentofix® X (polymer-coated) or Carbofol® HDPE-only barrier for acidic or heavy-metal tailings. | Best — HDPE provides primary chemical barrier; GCL secondary backup | Always use Carbofol® HDPE as the primary barrier in acidic or heavy-metal leachate. For a secondary GCL barrier in acidic tailings (pH < 4) or high polyvalent cation environments, specify Bentofix® X (polymer-coated grade) — standard Bentofix® grades are not suitable under these conditions. |
| Subgrade Requirement | Compacted, sharp-free subgrade or Secutex® protection layer mandatory | Requires moisture for hydration; performs well on irregular subgrades | Most adaptable - GCL conforms to uneven surfaces; HDPE provides impermeability | Rocky or uneven subgrade: composite system preferred |
| Installation on Steep Slopes | Available with textured surface for improved friction angle | Reinforced needle-punched construction increases shear strength | Secugrid® or Secutex® may be required for frictional stability | Slopes > 30°: consult Naue engineering for composite system stability analysis |
| Self-Healing / Redundancy | Not self-healing — weld integrity via CQA and air-channel testing | Self-sealing bentonite swells to close minor damage | Self-sealing GCL provides a redundancy layer for any HDPE defect | High-consequence TSFs (deep ponds, sensitive sites): composite mandatory |
| Closure & Capping | Carbofol® suitable as an impermeable barrier in a capping system | Bentofix® used as a capping mineral barrier; self-sealing supports post-closure performance | Composite capping for highest performance: Carbofol® + Bentofix® + Secudrain® | Closure of active TSF: composite system recommended per MAC TSF Guidelines |